DoctorMCAT Student Reviews & MCAT Testimonials
Every review below comes from a real student who worked one-on-one with Dr. Stuart Donnelly. Names include last initials for privacy, but each testimonial is verifiable upon request.
Students Who Reached Elite MCAT Scores
"Dr. Donnelly's methods completely transformed how I approach the MCAT. I came to him specifically for CARS, but what he taught me carried over to every section. He offered multiple explanations until I truly grasped the logic behind each question. I ended up with a 130 on CARS and a 525 overall. His practice materials — including full-lengths — let me target my weaknesses precisely. I went from constantly running out of time to finishing with minutes to spare."
"Stuart adapted his teaching specifically to my learning style, and the results speak for themselves. My MCAT score jumped 17 points to a 523 — a perfect 132 on the Bio section plus 130 on Chem/Phys, 130 on CARS, and 131 on Psych/Soc. His ability to identify and address my individual weaknesses made all the difference."
"Stuart's passage-deconstruction strategies gave me a completely new way to approach exam questions. After only a handful of sessions, my confidence surged. Final result: 518 overall / 97th percentile — 130 Chem/Phys, 130 Bio, 127 CARS, 131 Psych/Soc. His guidance was instrumental."
Students Who Made the Biggest Jumps
"I had taken the MCAT multiple times with disappointing results and even tried Kaplan twice. Dr. Donnelly's approach is fundamentally different from anything else out there — he focuses on how you think about the test, not just what you know. In ten weeks, my score went from the 66th percentile to the 92nd percentile. If you are anywhere in the country, his online sessions are just as effective."
"After studying on my own, my first MCAT results were deeply disappointing — especially in Physics and Gen Chem. Two months of intensive work with Stuart raised my Chem/Phys score by 7 points and my overall MCAT by 13 points. His explanations were thorough and clear, and he even stayed in touch after my exam to help with applications."
"Stuart was helpful, patient, and flexible throughout our spring sessions. He made the Bio and physical science passages far more approachable. When my results came back, I was thrilled — my score climbed 11 points to a 515. There is no way I would have performed that well without his tutoring."
"I took the MCAT twice before with terrible results despite doing well in my undergraduate coursework. Stuart met with me twice a week over Skype for five months. He explained technical concepts with extraordinary thoroughness and, crucially, taught me how to approach each question type. My CARS percentile increased by 60 points. Thanks to Stuart, I gained admission to the University of Washington School of Medicine."
"Dr. Donnelly gave me both the confidence and the tools to succeed on my retake. My score jumped 9 points. He is extraordinarily knowledgeable across every MCAT section and is beyond patient. Both my Skype sessions and in-person sessions were outstanding — not a single complaint."
"Stuart genuinely cares about his students doing well. He helped me grasp general chemistry concepts far more quickly than I could have alone, and his CARS strategy was remarkably effective — my score in that section alone rose by 7 points. Final result: 516 overall."
Students Who Shared Their Final MCAT Results
"I came to Dr. Donnelly just three weeks before my exam, desperately needing a CARS strategy. In only three lessons, my practice exam scores in that section jumped 30 percentiles. On test day, I scored in the 95th percentile overall. Stuart is professional, kind, and genuinely invested in your success."
"When I finally checked my score, I discovered I had achieved a 515 / 94th percentile. The relief was immense. I could never have scored a 129 in CARS without Stuart's methods and expertise. His approach to passage-based questions is unlike anything I encountered elsewhere."
"When I started, I had no idea what to expect from the MCAT. After about 2.5 months with Stuart, I scored a 514 / 91st percentile — including a 129 CARS (95th percentile) and a 131 in Psych/Soc (99th percentile!). His one-on-one attention let me focus on my personal weak spots rather than following a rigid group curriculum."
"I scored a 514 on my MCAT! Stuart's structured approach and personalized attention made all the difference in my preparation."
"Got my MCAT score back: 514 with a 132 in CARS. Stuart's CARS strategies were exactly what I needed to push through the section I had been dreading most. Very happy with the outcome."
"I was confident in chemistry but struggling with physics. Dr. Donnelly sharpened my physics skills over Skype sessions, and I walked into test day feeling prepared. I scored in the 97th percentile for the Chemical and Physical Foundations section. No matter where you live, give Stuart a try — online tutoring works brilliantly."
What Students Say About Working with Dr. Donnelly
"DoctorMCAT is the finest tutoring service I have ever experienced. Stuart has nearly 20 years of experience and it shows in every lesson. He was patient, funny, and knowledgeable across every MCAT section. When I expressed embarrassment about my low starting scores, he reassured me that my MCAT number did not define me. He taught me the right strategies for CARS and Physical Sciences that made everything clearer. I have recommended him to at least three friends and they are all equally happy."
"Stuart is the most patient MCAT tutor I have encountered. His one-on-one approach lets you learn at your own speed and focus on your weakest areas. He was also incredibly flexible with scheduling — I worked full-time and he accommodated evening sessions without any issue. His comprehensive library of MCAT materials from Kaplan, ExamKrackers, Princeton Review, and Berkeley Review means he can choose the passages most relevant to your needs."
"My daughter worked with Dr. Donnelly for three months and the transformation was remarkable. He zeroed in on her weaknesses and provided enormous insight. His strategic advice for the MCAT was invaluable. Within three months her scores improved significantly. Beyond his expertise, Stuart is simply one of those genuinely smart people who also knows how to teach."
"Dr. Donnelly's tutoring is fundamentally different from mainstream review programs. He isolates your individual weaknesses and builds a strategy around your specific needs — not a generic curriculum designed for the masses. He quickly understood my thought process and helped me break old habits and develop stronger test-taking skills to get the higher score I was after."
"Dr. Donnelly is a wonderful teacher who quickly identifies weaknesses and, in many cases, turns them into strengths. He always has a structured lesson plan with targeted homework and dedicates time to reviewing problem areas from the previous session. His patience, humor, and warmth make standardized test preparation almost enjoyable."
"The one-on-one attention from Dr. Donnelly was exactly what I needed after a disappointing Kaplan prep course. I never felt embarrassed asking basic questions — Stuart was patient and explained every concept in detail until I understood. He was also consistently available via email or phone between sessions."
Additional Student Testimonials
"I received multiple offers to medical school and have narrowed it down to GW in DC and PCOM in Philly. I am thrilled to be headed to school in August. Thank you so much for all your help and support throughout this process."
"I have some wonderful news — I was accepted into medical school! Thank you so much for all your help, time, and dedication. You are truly the best."
"I scored a 31 on the MCAT! I have had several interviews and just received my first acceptance. So happy to know I am definitely going to med school."
"Dr. Donnelly has numerous techniques to simplify everything — from passages to math equations to advanced physics concepts. We met both in person and via Skype. He provided all the study materials, was incredibly patient, and was an outstanding instructor overall. Anyone taking the MCAT should work with Stuart — you will see results."
"My daughter improved immensely because of her work with Stuart. She developed much better study habits and took genuine control of her academics. Our experience with Dr. Donnelly was exceptional from start to finish."
"Dr. Donnelly tutored my son in Physics and the results were remarkable. He taught problem-solving shortcuts that helped my son work faster and more accurately. My son constantly talks about how Stuart's skills transcend beyond physics into his regular coursework. Stuart was also excellent at accommodating our scheduling needs."
"Dr. Donnelly is patient, supportive, and clear when explaining difficult questions. He also encouraged me to work through problems independently, which proved extremely beneficial. He created an atmosphere where I actually looked forward to tackling each practice section. If you need standardized test preparation, Stuart is the person to call."
"Dr. Donnelly helped me build the confidence I was lacking, which dramatically improved my test performance. I used to be terrified of Physics, but Stuart taught me strategies for breaking down complicated problems into simple, manageable steps. He reviewed every concept in depth and asked questions to confirm I truly understood. He made test prep enjoyable and fulfilling."
"Stuart was patient, kind, and willing to work with me across multiple subject areas to improve not just my score but my fundamental understanding of the questions. His schedule is flexible and he adapts to what each student needs. My score went up dramatically and I would recommend DoctorMCAT to anyone preparing for the MCAT."
"I have had several interviews and just received my first acceptance. So happy to know I am definitely headed to medical school. Thank you, Dr. Donnelly!"
Ready to Write Your Own Success Story?
Join the hundreds of students who have raised their MCAT scores with Dr. Donnelly. Book a free 30-minute consultation today — no obligation, just an honest assessment of how private tutoring can help you reach your goals.
